Skip to main content

What does the fan say .......

WORLD CUP T20 FINALS – A REAL-TIME FAN VIEW

At Fantain, we run a real time game called Playcall©.  In this game, cricket fans take decisions that captain’s make in real-time The questions are asked before the actual decisions are taken in the field of play and answers locked in.  In effect, the fans act like captains. Fans know and understand a lot about the sports they love, and how the fans feel about the action is very interesting to understand. 

So here is what the fans felt during the finals between Sri Lanka and India.  And remember, none of this is retrospective.  The fans have decided the following at the same time the captains were deciding…


                                      TEAM COMPOSITION

Ajinkya Rahane failed with the bat. Should Dhoni have played Shikhar Dhawan instead of Rahane. 19% of fans selected Shikhar Dhawan while 81% opted for Rahane.


What about Yuvaraj? Should he have played the match in the first place. Yes, said 64% of fans. 36% said that either Shikhar Dhawan or Stuart Binny should have replaced Yuvaraj in the playing XI.

What about India’s second seamer? 39% of fans selected Shami and 61% selected Mohit Sharma in the team. Surprisingly, not one fan selected Varun Aaron.



                                      YUVRAJ SINGH


Hindsight is 20-20. Many of us felt Dhoni made a mistake by asking Yuvaraj to bat at No.4. But guess what, an overwhelming 70% of fans also selected Yuvaraj to bat at that position. 24% decided that Suresh Raina should have batted then and 6% felt that M S Dhoni should have batted at No.4.
BUT, at the end of the game, we asked our fans to play selector. To a question on whether Yuvaraj deserved a place in the Indian XI in T20 internationals, 76% felt that Yuvaraj was past his prime while 24% felt that this was just a poor outing for Yuvaraj.

                       DHONI’S DECISION-MAKING DURING THE MATCH

There were a few pivotal points in the game where the direction could have changed because of Dhoni’s decisions. Let us analyse some of them:

  • Dhoni asked Suresh Raina to bowl before Ravindra Jadeja Was this a mistake? This was a close one. 53% of fans made the same decision that Dhoni made while 47% of fans decided that Jadeja should have bowled first.
  • Both Ashwin (1-0-4-1) & Amit Mishra (1-0-1-0) bowled excellent first overs. But Dhoni did not give both of them another over in the same spell. Was this a mistake? What would you have done if you were the captain? Well, 64% of fans would have kept Ashwin and Amit on for a longer spell. Only 36% of fans took the same decision that Dhoni took.

 

            FINAL ANALYSIS OF CAPTAINCY OF BOTH DHONI AND MALINGA

At the end of the match, we asked the fans how they rated the captaincy of the Dhoni and Malinga

86% of fans thought that Malinga’s captaincy was either brilliant or good.   Only 46% of fans thought Dhoni’s captaincy was either brilliant or good.  Clearly, the fans thought Malinga was the better captain on the day.  But, this question is asked in hindsight.  It is easy to criticize captains when they lose a match.  Important thing is to see if we would have taken a different decision if we were the captain We measure this through what we call ‘Fan Alignment Score’.

    How aligned were the captain’s to the fans.In other words, how much did the fans concur with the decisions made by the captain. We calculate this score using a proprietary algorithm and here are the numbers
    Dhoni made decisions more aligned with India fans during the game, a tad more than what Malinga made. This underlines the difficulty and snap-decision making process captains go through. In our experience, any alignment score above 50% is very good, indicating good alignment with fans and therefore, presumably, the best ‘crowd-sourced’ decision. 



    WHY ARE WE DOING THIS?

    There are a lot of polling bots out there that ask random questions during a game, show the results and move on. We look at this differently. We identify and segment fans, get real time inputs, and using deep data analysis and game heuristics, provide insightful views of the game from a fan’s perspective. This is ultimately a great gaming platform for the fans to engage them, in real-time, in the field of action, a great tool for captains and players to analyse what their fans perceive of them, and a great medium for franchises, brands and other stakeholders to reach out to different segments of the sporting audience.

    For more information, please get in touch with us at anand@fantain.com.

    Comments

    Popular posts from this blog

    From all of us Fans to Players & Officials: Please don't treat us with kid gloves

    As any fan will tell you, we not just love, but understand the sport and our teams like no one else. And that’s also why they keep bankrolling the big fat salaries of the players, the profits of the clubs and the boondoggle of officials. The recently concluded test match raised, in my mind, three instances where the thought process seems to be – it is OK for us to handle it, but it is too hot for fans . Common, now, please don’t treat us with kid gloves. One: The first one, inevitably, is about the DRS and taking the dugouts inputs in it. The rules are clear – the decision to ask for a decision review stays with the players on the field. Within a few seconds of the umpires’ decision, the batting team can dispute an out decision or the bowling team can dispute a not-out decision, without consulting with anyone outside the playing field. The controversy of Smith’s ‘brain-fade’ and Kohli’s allegations have played out ad nauseam on TV and cyberspace, so I will spare you that

    Need for co-ed sports

    Now, this is hardly a feminist piece. I am not here to tell you that women can do anything that men can and better too. One, you know it too. Two, this is hardly about women. I am not here to praise women and demand better rights. I am talking about the possibility that the entire field of sports can take a whole new meaning if gender is not made the criterion. So this is how the idea for the blog started. The Women’s Indian Cricket Team performed really well at the world cup this year. Mithali Raj praised her team for their hard work, persistence, and passion for the game. She also added that there should be an IPL tournament in the country for the women’s team now. Raj believes that the team’s fantastic game has increased the fan following for the women’s team as well and that they have earned their place here. While I am honestly not sure about an IPL tournament for women, it did get me thinking. Why not mixed sports? Now that girls play almost all the games that the guys do, w

    Editor’s Pick: England Vs Australia

    Group A. Wide Open. With Bangladesh having won the match, Australia and New Zealand have been dumped to the bottom two. This adds pressure to the match today. A do-or-die clash always has its charm. Coming back to us fans, while the men hope to do a good job on the field, we need to pick a good lineup for our dream team. Let’s get on with it. England first. England is on top with four points from two wins, yes. But there is no need to slack and take it easy. They would want their best men in front. 77% have added Alex Hales to their lineup. With a salary of 8, I’d want him on my team too. But then, that’s just me. Jason Roy is under pressure to perform, so he will want to put on a good show. I might risk him as well. Ben Stokes and Jos Buttler, still fresh from their IPL tournaments are pretty good bets. Joe Root is a must, along with Morgan of course. The Captain. Now, the bowlers. Adil Rashid, Liam Plunkett and Jake Ball should be in. Australia Star